The Idea of Indian Citizenship: The Promise That Could Make Religious Electorates Unnecessary
When India became independent in 1947, it inherited a problem that was much older than Partition. How could people belonging to different religions, languages, castes, regions and cultures live together in one political community without allowing the largest community to permanently dominate the smaller ones? The Muslim League had offered one answer. It argued that Muslims were not merely a religious minority but a separate political nation. If Muslims were to be secure, they needed political safeguards based on their identity—and eventually, in the League's view, their own state. But there was another answer. It was the idea that ultimately became the foundation of the Indian Republic: You should not need to belong to a political majority in order to be an equal citizen. That idea was extraordinarily ambitious. And if India can make it work in practice, it offers something much more powerful than separate political representation for every religious community. It offers a way out ...